By Michael Phillips | Wisconsin Bay News
An expansive investigation by the Chicago Tribune has laid bare a troubling pattern of fraud tied to the federal Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) in Illinois—one that extends beyond private abuse of pandemic relief and into the ranks of government itself.
According to the Tribune’s December 29, 2025 report, hundreds of public employees across Illinois state government, Cook County, and the City of Chicago improperly obtained forgivable PPP loans meant to help struggling small businesses during the COVID-19 crisis. The findings underscore how weak oversight, rushed federal spending, and long-standing governance problems combined to produce a predictable result: taxpayer money lost, public trust damaged, and accountability arriving years too late.
A Program Built for Speed, Not Safeguards
The PPP was created under the CARES Act in early 2020, with bipartisan support and a clear goal—keep workers paid during emergency shutdowns. Speed was prioritized over verification, with applicants largely self-certifying income and business activity.
Nationally, that trade-off proved costly. The Small Business Administration’s inspector general has estimated tens of billions of dollars in improper payments. Illinois’ experience, however, stands out because of who took advantage of the system: government employees entrusted with public service.
State Employees Caught Gaming the System
The Illinois Office of the Executive Inspector General reported that in fiscal year 2025 alone, investigators found “reasonable cause” of misconduct in roughly three-quarters of completed PPP cases involving state workers. More than 100 employees across agencies such as Human Services, Corrections, Juvenile Justice, and Children and Family Services improperly received over $2.8 million in loans—often by claiming nonexistent businesses or fabricated income.
In many cases, the amounts hovered around $20,000 to $40,000, conveniently within the range that could be forgiven with minimal scrutiny. More than 200 employees have since been fired or resigned. Several cases were referred for prosecution.
Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul has pursued criminal charges in select cases, resulting mostly in probation, restitution, and community service rather than prison time—raising questions about whether consequences match the scale of the breach.
Cook County and Chicago: A Familiar Pattern
Cook County investigations uncovered dozens of additional cases, including within the Sheriff’s Office and Circuit Court Clerk’s office. Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle emphasized that the misconduct involved only a small fraction of the county’s 22,000 employees. That may be statistically true—but politically unsatisfying to taxpayers who expect higher standards from public servants.
At the city level, Chicago Inspector General Deborah Witzburg initially flagged nearly 1,000 potential PPP cases among city workers before narrowing the focus due to staffing and resource limits. Her office has substantiated several cases so far, with dozens more still under investigation, prioritizing police officers and employees in financially sensitive roles.
Witzburg summed up the issue bluntly: the PPP suffered from “inadequate controls,” and it was especially disturbing to see people committed to public service defrauding the government they worked for.
More Than Isolated Bad Actors
From a center-right standpoint, this scandal is not just about individual misconduct. It reflects systemic failure:
- Federal programs designed too fast and too loosely, inviting fraud on a massive scale.
- Insufficient clawbacks and prosecutions, signaling low risk for abuse.
- A culture of complacency in one-party states, where accountability often follows media exposure rather than proactive oversight.
Illinois’ long history of corruption—from convicted governors to utility bribery schemes—adds context. While most public employees did not commit fraud, the fact that so many felt comfortable doing so suggests deeper institutional problems that cannot be dismissed as a few bad apples.
The Lesson for Future Crises
Pandemic relief was necessary. Fraud was not inevitable—but it was predictable. As Washington debates future emergency spending, Illinois’ PPP scandal serves as a cautionary tale: speed without safeguards invites abuse, and public trust is the first casualty.
Accountability matters not just for recovering dollars, but for restoring confidence that government can act decisively without acting recklessly. For taxpayers in Illinois—and neighboring states like Wisconsin—that lesson remains unfinished business.
Support Independent Journalism
Wisconsin Bay News is part of the Bay News Media Network — a growing group of independent, reader-supported newsrooms covering government accountability, courts, public safety, and institutional failures across the country.
📰 Support independent journalism that isn’t funded by political parties, corporations, or government agencies
📩 Submit tips or documents securely — if you see something wrong, we want to know
Independent reporting only works when readers stay engaged. Your attention, tips, and support help keep these stories alive.
Wisconsin Bay News 
Leave a comment